Try 1x for free
1x is a curated photo gallery where every image have been handpicked for their high quality. With a membership, you can take part in the curation process and also try uploading your own best photos and see if they are good enough to make it all the way.
Right now you get one month for free when signing up for a PRO account. You can cancel anytime without being charged.
Try for free   No thanks
We use cookies
This website uses cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience for the following purposes: to enable basic functionality of the website, to provide a better experience on the website, to measure your interest in our products and services and to personalize marketing interactions.
I agree   I deny
Forum
Critique
High-Key
#GULLS# HIGHKEY#SNOW#WINTER#BIRDS
Kimberly CREW 
2 years ago — Editorial team

Shot at f11, ISO 800, shutter speed 1/500 sec. Intentionally exposed to the right. I was looking for a more painterly style so the snow is more blown out. Looking for those second set of eyes feedback. Thanks, Kim

 

Theo Luycx
2 years ago

Kimberly,

High-key is not my first priority but I played a little bit with your composition and I think in a strange way. I show you 3 images the first and third are possibilities the second is only to explain what I did. The first one. I brought him in camera raw and darkend. You become much blue in it and I used the pipette of the white balance to reduce the blue.. With the radial gradient I darkend the birds a fraction. But the left upper and right lower triangles were not white enough. I selected them each after another with the lasso and above the stumper on 60px for soft borders. In each triangle I used the pipette of the white balance. for me an eccaptble result. My followinging action for the third one was to darken the first one much more see the second. There I did the two corner in the same way. But now the birds were much to dark. I selected them in the first one with the lasso around all three with 60px and brought this selection in the second one. and made one layer and darkend a little bit iin the middle of the birds. A strange action but see if you can use something. Theo-senior critic.

 

PS. What I forgot, I like your version too like he is now, I lost perhaps too much white Perhaps you can use a fraction of my darken actions. Find your own way and perhaps you become better advices.

Edited: 2 years ago by Theo Luycx
Theo Luycx
2 years ago

Kimberly, I was not happy with the result, not enough white. I brought nr 3 iback in Camera raw and used only the white sleeve. below the result. A fracvtion better I think.Theo-senior critic.

 

 

Edited: 2 years ago by Theo Luycx
Kimberly CREW 
2 years ago — Editorial team

Thank you Theo, yes, an interesting take on this image, I considered bringing in more color and tones, it's nice to see how you have interpreted this one, Many thanks

Kim

Lucie Gagnon CREW 
2 years ago — Senior critic
Kimberly CREW 

Shot at f11, ISO 800, shutter speed 1/500 sec. Intentionally exposed to the right. I was looking for a more painterly style so the snow is more blown out. Looking for those second set of eyes feedback. Thanks, Kim

 

Hello Kimberly,


Welcome to the Critique forum. I  like your image very much and I do high key photography myself sometimes.  Looking at your picture, I do find that there is too much white on the top left quadrant (even for a high key) and I find that the dried up flowers on the right was too close to the edge.

So I brought your picture in Photoshop Elements 21 and did the followwing.

First, I moved the dried flowers closer to the birds. Then I cropped the picture tighter, in a 4x6 format.

I then added some details and Tonal Contrast in Nik Collection Color EfexPro. I concentrated these changes mostly on the birds and less on the snow around them. 

Then I adjusted the levels a little to brighten the image and add a little more contrast.

I adjusted a little the brightness in the top left section because it was as blinding as snow in winter!  To do that, I used the Burn tool.

Et voilà!

Hope these suggestions are helpful and thank you for posting your picture here for us to look at.

Lucie s.c.

 

 

Edited: 2 years ago by Lucie Gagnon
Kimberly CREW 
2 years ago — Editorial team
Lucie Gagnon CREW 
Kimberly CREW 

Shot at f11, ISO 800, shutter speed 1/500 sec. Intentionally exposed to the right. I was looking for a more painterly style so the snow is more blown out. Looking for those second set of eyes feedback. Thanks, Kim

 

Hello Kimberley , (I Hope this is the right Kimberley! )


Welcome to the Critique forum. I  like your image very much and I do high key photography myself sometimes.  Looking at your picture, I do find that there is too much white on the top left quadrant (even for a high key) and I find that the dried up flowers on the right was too close to the edge.

So I brought your picture in Photoshop Elements 21 and did the followwing.

First, I moved the dried flowers closer to the birds. Then I cropped the picture tighter, in a 4x6 format.

I then added some details and Tonal Contrast in Nik Collection Color EfexPro. I concentrated these changes mostly on the birds and less on the snow around them. 

Then I adjusted the levels a little to brighten the image and add a little more contrast.

I adjusted a little the brightness in the top left section because it was as blinding as snow in winter!  To do that, I used the Burn tool.

Et voilà!

Hope these suggestions are helpful and thank you for posting your picture here for us to look at.

Lucie s.c.

 

 

Thank you Lucie, I really like your edits and a great idea to move the flower closer, I debated whether to crop it out but felt it added something. Taking down the brightness too was a great suggestion. ( Kimberly without the "e"!!) Kim is easier

Lucie Gagnon CREW 
2 years ago — Senior critic
Kimberly CREW 
Lucie Gagnon CREW 
Kimberly CREW 

Shot at f11, ISO 800, shutter speed 1/500 sec. Intentionally exposed to the right. I was looking for a more painterly style so the snow is more blown out. Looking for those second set of eyes feedback. Thanks, Kim

 

Hello dKimberley , (I Hope this is the right Kimberley! )


Welcome to the Critique forum. I  like your image very much and I do high key photography myself sometimes.  Looking at your picture, I do find that there is too much white on the top left quadrant (even for a high key) and I find that the dried up flowers on the right was too close to the edge.

So I brought your picture in Photoshop Elements 21 and did the followwing.

First, I moved the dried flowers closer to the birds. Then I cropped the picture tighter, in a 4x6 format.

I then added some details and Tonal Contrast in Nik Collection Color EfexPro. I concentrated these changes mostly on the birds and less on the snow around them. 

Then I adjusted the levels a little to brighten the image and add a little more contrast.

I adjusted a little the brightness in the top left section because it was as blinding as snow in winter!  To do that, I used the Burn tool.

Et voilà!

Hope these suggestions are helpful and thank you for posting your picture here for us to look at.

Lucie s.c.

 

 

Thank you Lucie, I really like your edits and a great idea to move the flower closer, I debated whether to crop it out but felt it added something. Taking down the brightness too was a great suggestion. ( Kimberly without the "e"!!) Kim is easier

Glad you like the suggestions I made. I too thought the flowers added something and should not be cropped out.

I corrected your name in my post! 

Greetings from a fellow Canadian!

Lucie

Edited: 2 years ago by Lucie Gagnon
Cicek Kiral CREW 
2 years ago — Senior critic

Hello, Kim

Welcome to the forum. This is a beautiful image. I really like it. There are few things s though. First of all the highlights are too bright. This prevents us to look less than needed at the photo. The other thing I want to stress is about the composition I think coming closer to the subject would be better here. I prepared an example for you. First I cropped your image and later I increased the vibrancy, texture, clarity and I enhanced the Inge by increasing dehase. The result looks quite painterly I think. Have good light. Cicek Kiral...

 

Kimberly CREW 
2 years ago — Editorial team

Thank you Cicek, what a wonderful enhancement. I love it